The FN High Power and the Springfield Armory SA-35 are both iconic 9mm pistols based on the legendary Browning High Power design. While sharing a common ancestor, they boast distinct features and characteristics that cater to different preferences and needs. This in-depth comparison will explore the key differences between the FN High Power and the Springfield SA-35, helping you decide which pistol best suits your needs.
Design and Construction
Both pistols retain the core design elements of the original Browning High Power: a single-action, 9mm, double-stack magazine, and a compact yet powerful profile. However, subtle differences exist in their construction and materials.
FN High Power
The FN High Power, produced by Fabrique Nationale (FN) Herstal, is known for its robust construction, typically using forged steel components. This results in a heavier, more durable pistol that can withstand significant use. The finish is generally high-quality, offering good resistance to wear and corrosion. The ergonomics are a point of frequent discussion, with some finding the grip angle less comfortable than modern designs.
Springfield SA-35
The Springfield SA-35 is a more modern interpretation of the High Power design, often incorporating modern manufacturing techniques and materials. While still employing steel, Springfield sometimes uses different alloys or processes resulting in a slightly lighter pistol than the FN High Power. The finishes on the SA-35 can vary depending on the model and can include a variety of coatings enhancing durability and aesthetics. The SA-35 generally has a slightly improved grip angle compared to the original FN design making it more comfortable for many shooters.
Table 1: Material and Construction Comparison
| Feature | FN High Power | Springfield SA-35 |
|---|---|---|
| Frame Material | Forged Steel | Steel (various alloys possible) |
| Slide Material | Forged Steel | Steel (various alloys possible) |
| Finish | Typically blued or other high quality finishes | Varies by model (e.g., parkerized, cerakote) |
| Weight | Generally heavier | Generally lighter |
Ergonomics and Handling
The ergonomics of both pistols are a matter of personal preference. The FN High Power's grip angle, inherited from the original design, can feel less comfortable for some shooters, especially those with larger hands. Springfield, through their SA-35 models, has sometimes addressed this by offering a slightly more modern grip angle which is more suitable for a wider range of hand sizes.
Both pistols are relatively compact, making them suitable for concealed carry, though the slightly lighter weight of the SA-35 might be preferable for all-day carry. However, the heavier weight of the FN High Power helps to mitigate recoil.
Trigger and Accuracy
Both the FN High Power and the Springfield SA-35 are known for their relatively crisp triggers, although the exact feel can vary based on specific model and individual variations. Both can deliver exceptional accuracy given the right shooter and ammunition, although some shooters may find subtle differences based on their preferred grip and handling style.
Features and Variations
Both manufacturers offer various models of their respective pistols, each with its own set of features. FN High Power models may include different finishes, sights, and even some limited edition versions. Springfield Armory SA-35s also boast various models including different finishes and sight options.
Pricing and Availability
Pricing for both the FN High Power and the Springfield SA-35 can vary depending on the specific model, condition, and retailer. Generally, FN High Powers, especially older or discontinued models, can command higher prices due to their collectability. Springfield SA-35s typically offer a more accessible price point. Availability can fluctuate, with some models being more readily available than others.
Conclusion: Which Pistol is Right for You?
Choosing between the FN High Power and the Springfield SA-35 largely depends on personal preferences and intended use.
-
Choose the FN High Power if: You prioritize a robust, traditionally built pistol with a proven track record, and value the classic design. You may also prefer a heavier pistol that mitigates recoil.
-
Choose the Springfield SA-35 if: You prefer a more modern interpretation of the design, possibly with enhanced ergonomics and potentially a lower price point. You prioritize a slightly lighter pistol for easier daily carry.
Ultimately, handling both pistols if possible and considering your individual needs and preferences is essential before making a decision. Researching specific models within each line is also crucial to get the full picture of features and pricing.