The Smith & Wesson Model 66 and the Model 686 are two legendary revolvers that have captivated shooters for decades. Both are .357 Magnum capable, offering impressive power and stopping power, but their differences lie in materials, weight, and overall feel. This in-depth comparison will explore the nuances of each model to help you decide which one is the right fit for your needs. Understanding the distinctions between the Model 66 and the Model 686 is crucial for any serious revolver enthusiast.
Key Differences: Model 66 vs. Model 686
The core difference between the Model 66 and the 686 boils down to their construction materials. This seemingly small detail significantly impacts weight, feel, and overall durability.
Material: Steel vs. Stainless Steel
-
Model 66: Constructed from carbon steel, this revolver offers a classic look and feel. Carbon steel is strong, but susceptible to rust if not properly cared for. Regular cleaning and lubrication are essential. The blued finish on the Model 66 is aesthetically pleasing to many, offering a traditional firearm look.
-
Model 686: Made from stainless steel, this revolver is naturally resistant to rust and corrosion. This makes it a more practical choice for environments with varying weather conditions or higher humidity. The stainless steel finish requires less maintenance. However, some prefer the look of the blued steel on the Model 66.
Weight: A Noticeable Difference
The material difference directly translates into a significant weight variation:
-
Model 66: Typically lighter due to the use of carbon steel. This makes it more comfortable for extended shooting sessions for some shooters. However, the lighter weight can also contribute to more felt recoil.
-
Model 686: Considerably heavier due to the stainless steel construction. The added weight reduces felt recoil, making it a more manageable firearm, particularly for higher-powered .357 Magnum loads. This increased weight also contributes to better stability during aiming.
Performance and Handling: A Side-by-Side Comparison
Both revolvers offer excellent performance, but their weight differences impact handling:
Recoil Management: Weight Matters
-
Model 66: The lighter weight translates to more noticeable recoil, especially when firing .357 Magnum rounds. While manageable, experienced shooters might find it slightly snappier.
-
Model 686: The heavier weight significantly mitigates recoil, offering a smoother shooting experience, even with powerful ammunition. This makes it an excellent choice for beginners or those sensitive to recoil.
Accuracy: Negligible Differences
Both the Model 66 and the Model 686 are known for their accuracy. With proper technique and quality ammunition, both models are capable of excellent shot placement. Any accuracy difference is negligible and mostly attributable to shooter skill and consistency rather than the revolver itself.
Maintenance: Steel vs. Stainless Steel Considerations
The different materials require distinct maintenance approaches:
-
Model 66 (Carbon Steel): Requires more frequent cleaning and lubrication to prevent rust and corrosion. Regular oiling is crucial, especially after shooting in damp conditions. Proper storage in a dry environment is essential.
-
Model 686 (Stainless Steel): Less susceptible to rust, requiring less frequent cleaning. While regular cleaning is still recommended, it can be spaced out more compared to the carbon steel Model 66.
Choosing the Right Revolver: Factors to Consider
The best choice between the Model 66 and the Model 686 depends on individual preferences and intended use:
-
Choose the Model 66 if: You prefer a lighter-weight revolver, appreciate the classic blued steel finish, and are diligent about gun maintenance. You might also prioritize cost, as Model 66s are sometimes available at a lower price point than comparable 686s.
-
Choose the Model 686 if: You prioritize reduced recoil, prefer the rust resistance of stainless steel, and value ease of maintenance. The heavier weight might be advantageous for those with less shooting experience.
Case Study: Comparing User Reviews
An analysis of online forums and reviews shows a recurring theme: shooters with experience often appreciate the lighter feel and snappy recoil of the Model 66. Beginners and those sensitive to recoil overwhelmingly prefer the added weight and softer shooting experience of the Model 686.
Conclusion: The Perfect Revolver is Subjective
Ultimately, the "better" revolver depends on the individual shooter's needs and preferences. Both the Model 66 and the Model 686 are excellent firearms with a rich history and proven reliability. Carefully consider the factors discussed above to determine which model best suits your shooting style and priorities. Visiting a gun range and handling both revolvers is highly recommended before making a purchase.