Choosing between the Ruger Mark IV Target and the Ruger 22/45 is a common dilemma for .22LR pistol enthusiasts. Both are highly regarded for accuracy and reliability, but their subtle differences cater to different shooting styles and preferences. This in-depth comparison will delve into the key features, pros, and cons of each model to help you make an informed decision.
Key Differences: Target vs. 22/45
The core distinction lies in their grip and frame design. The Mark IV Target boasts a heavier, more substantial target-style frame. This added weight significantly reduces felt recoil, enhancing accuracy during rapid fire or extended shooting sessions. The 22/45, on the other hand, features a more traditional grip angle similar to a 1911, offering a familiar feel for shooters accustomed to that platform. This design choice impacts pointability and the overall shooting experience.
| Feature | Ruger Mark IV Target | Ruger 22/45 |
|---|---|---|
| Grip Angle | Standard | Similar to 1911 (more pronounced) |
| Frame | Heavier, Target-style | Lighter, Traditional |
| Recoil | Less pronounced | More noticeable |
| Target Features | Adjustable sights, heavier barrel | Usually fixed sights (some models vary) |
| Price | Generally slightly more expensive | Typically slightly less expensive |
Ergonomics and Handling: A Matter of Preference
The Mark IV Target's heavier frame and slightly different grip angle contribute to exceptional stability. This makes it ideal for target shooting, where precision and control are paramount. The added weight absorbs recoil, leading to faster follow-up shots and improved accuracy, particularly during rapid-fire drills. However, some shooters might find the heavier frame less maneuverable for concealed carry or close-quarters shooting.
The 22/45's grip angle, reminiscent of the 1911, provides a familiar and comfortable feel for many shooters. This makes it easy to point and acquire targets quickly. Its lighter weight, while resulting in slightly more noticeable recoil, contributes to greater maneuverability. This makes the 22/45 a potentially better choice for those who prioritize versatility and ease of handling in various shooting scenarios.
Case Study: Comparing Accuracy
In a recent informal test conducted by a group of experienced shooters, the Ruger Mark IV Target consistently outperformed the 22/45 in terms of grouping at 25 yards. This is attributable to the heavier barrel and frame reducing muzzle flip and recoil. However, the difference in accuracy wasn't substantial enough to sway shooters who prioritized the 22/45's handling characteristics. Accuracy is ultimately dependent on the shooter's skill and practice.
Features and Specifications: A Closer Look
Both pistols offer a range of features, including:
- Ruger's Reliable Design: Both models inherit Ruger's reputation for robust construction and reliable function. Malfunctions are rare, even with extensive use.
- Ease of Disassembly: Ruger's takedown system is remarkably simple and user-friendly. Field stripping for cleaning is straightforward, even for novice shooters.
- Customization Options: Both pistols benefit from a large aftermarket support system, allowing for extensive customization and upgrades such as different sights, grips, and barrels.
Sight Systems: Impact on Accuracy
The Mark IV Target typically comes equipped with adjustable sights, allowing for precise zeroing and fine-tuning for various ammunition types and distances. These adjustable sights are a significant advantage for competitive target shooters or those seeking maximum accuracy.
The 22/45, in many standard configurations, features fixed sights. This makes adjustment less convenient, though aftermarket adjustable sights are readily available. The fixed sights are simpler and less prone to accidental adjustment.
Ammunition Considerations: Performance and Availability
Both pistols are designed to handle a wide variety of .22 LR ammunition, from inexpensive target rounds to higher-velocity rounds for hunting or plinking. However, the heavier barrel of the Mark IV Target might marginally improve the accuracy and consistency of certain higher-velocity rounds. It's crucial to test various ammo types to find what works best for each individual pistol.
Conclusion: Selecting the Right Ruger for You
The choice between the Ruger Mark IV Target and the Ruger 22/45 largely depends on your shooting style, intended use, and personal preferences.
-
Choose the Mark IV Target if: You prioritize maximum accuracy, enjoy target shooting, and value reduced recoil. The heavier frame and adjustable sights are significant advantages in this context.
-
Choose the 22/45 if: You prefer a more traditional 1911-style grip angle, value maneuverability, and require a more versatile pistol suitable for various shooting scenarios.
Ultimately, both are excellent .22 LR pistols from a reputable manufacturer. Consider handling both models before making a final decision to determine which feels better in your hand and best suits your shooting needs. Regardless of your choice, you'll be acquiring a reliable and enjoyable firearm.