Choosing the right lower receiver for your AR-15 build is crucial. DPMS, a well-known manufacturer, offers two main generations of lowers: Gen 1 and Gen 2. While both are reliable, understanding the key differences can significantly impact your build's performance and longevity. This in-depth comparison will help you decide which generation best suits your needs.
Key Differences Between DPMS Gen 1 and Gen 2 Lower Receivers
The most significant distinctions between DPMS Gen 1 and Gen 2 lowers lie in their manufacturing processes and design features. Let's explore the specifics.
Material and Manufacturing
-
Gen 1: Typically made from forged 7075-T6 aluminum, known for its strength and durability. However, early Gen 1 lowers occasionally showed inconsistencies in machining, leading to some minor variations in fit and finish.
-
Gen 2: Also constructed from forged 7075-T6 aluminum, but with improvements in the manufacturing process. DPMS implemented tighter tolerances and enhanced quality control, resulting in more consistent and precise machining. This translates to improved part interchangeability and a smoother overall build experience.
Fire Control Group (FCG) Pin Configuration
-
Gen 1: Uses a single, larger diameter takedown pin. This design, while functional, can sometimes be slightly more difficult to remove and reinstall.
-
Gen 2: Employs a standard, dual-pin system for the takedown pins. This is the industry standard and is generally considered easier and faster to manipulate. This improvement significantly enhances ease of maintenance and field stripping.
Magazine Well Design
While both generations generally accommodate standard AR-15 magazines, subtle variations exist.
-
Gen 1: Some users have reported occasional minor feeding issues with certain magazines in Gen 1 lowers, though this isn't universally experienced.
-
Gen 2: DPMS refined the magazine well design in Gen 2, resulting in more consistent and reliable magazine insertion and feeding. This smoother magazine interaction is a notable improvement for many shooters.
Overall Finish and Aesthetics
-
Gen 1: Finish quality varied slightly across early production runs. While generally durable, some Gen 1 lowers might exhibit minor inconsistencies in surface finish.
-
Gen 2: DPMS focused on improving the overall finish and aesthetics of Gen 2 lowers. The consistent, high-quality finish contributes to a more professional look and feel.
Price Point
Generally, Gen 2 lowers command a slightly higher price than Gen 1 lowers. This price difference reflects the improved manufacturing processes and enhanced quality control implemented by DPMS.
Which Generation is Right for You?
The choice between a DPMS Gen 1 and Gen 2 lower receiver depends largely on your priorities and budget.
Consider Gen 1 if:
- Budget is a primary concern: Gen 1 lowers are usually more affordable.
- You're comfortable with potential minor variations: While most Gen 1 lowers function flawlessly, be aware of the possibility of slight variations in fit and finish.
Consider Gen 2 if:
- Reliability and consistency are paramount: Gen 2's improved manufacturing process results in a more reliable and consistent product.
- Ease of maintenance is important: The dual-pin takedown system makes field stripping and cleaning significantly easier.
- You prefer a more refined finish: Gen 2 lowers boast a superior and more consistent finish.
Case Study: Comparing Build Experiences
To illustrate the practical differences, let's compare two hypothetical builds: one using a Gen 1 lower and another using a Gen 2 lower.
Build A (Gen 1): During assembly, slight fitting adjustments were needed for some parts. The single takedown pin proved slightly more challenging to remove than expected. Magazine insertion was generally smooth, but one particular magazine exhibited occasional slight feeding inconsistencies.
Build B (Gen 2): Assembly was smooth and straightforward. The dual-pin takedown system was easy to operate. Magazine insertion and feeding were consistently reliable across multiple magazines.
This hypothetical comparison highlights the practical advantages of the improvements incorporated in the Gen 2 design.
Conclusion: DPMS Gen 1 vs Gen 2
Both DPMS Gen 1 and Gen 2 lower receivers are capable of forming the foundation for a reliable AR-15. However, the Gen 2 represents a clear step up in manufacturing consistency, ease of use, and overall quality. While the price difference might be a factor, the improvements in the Gen 2 design often justify the extra cost for many builders, particularly those prioritizing ease of use, reliability, and a superior overall experience. Ultimately, the best choice depends on your individual needs and priorities.